@unforth-ninawaters replied to your post
For drug use I think it depends what we’re defining as drugs. I tend not to think of pot as a drug, at least not in the dangerous way. It’s basically canon that Dean at least has smoked weed. Emotional abuse and manipulation for both Dean and Sam is also canon. For harder drugs, I’m not so sure (cocaine, heroine, etc) but I lean toward no – maybe psychotropics, that seems a little more in character – and I’m on the fence about physical abuse.
(pre-series mental illness is imo as much as a given as during-season mental illness)
The thing for physical abuse is…my inclination is that John didn’t hit them, didn’t beat them in the traditional sense. But I do think his neglect shaded into what would probably legally constitute physical abuse – both in terms of food deprivation, etc., but also in the “it’s just a little scratch quit being such a baby, be a man” kind of way – leaving them to suffer through injuries that COULD have been succored if John wasn’t so fixated on “toughening them up.”
And yeah, I agree that’s both Dean and Sam. I do NOT think in canon that John did any form of sexual abuse against the boys, nor do I think it very likely that Sam had to turn to prostitution – Dean would never have let that happen.
I can see psychotropics. I wouldn’t put it past Dean to at least try things here and there but I’m not sure if it would pass experimentation.
It’s funny to me because I posted a thing about Dean having anxiety a while back and the response was basically “yeah, totally”. I thought I was going to have to explain that one, but it seems like everyone I talk to is just like “yup, mental illness is a given”. Which is fine.
I can definitely see John letting them suffer through injuries he doesn’t deem “serious” enough. I don’t think they were ever hit or sexually abused, but I do think they could have been grabbed or smacked or shoved in ways that might’ve left bruises, even if they were unintentional. I seem to be the outlier in that respect, but I feel like it could have happened a few times. I don’t think John would have intentionally hit his kids, but I think he might have been rough with them.
And yeah, there is no way Sam would have had to turn to prostitution. Unless he was alone at the time, Dean wouldn’t allow it.