SamJess

who’s the werewolf and who’s the hunter:
Sam is a werewolf and Jess is a hunter. He’s never killed a person but he believes he’s terrible and dangerous. She doesn’t but that at all.
who’s the mermaid and who’s the fisherman:
Jess is the mermaid and Sam’s the fisherman. (I love a classic.)
who’s the witch and who’s the familiar:
Jess is a witch. Sam is her really, really big familiar. (Not a moose but like, maybe a retriever.) 
who’s the barista and who’s the coffee addict: 
Sam is a barista. Jess is a college student who’s trying really hard to keep her eyes open in the morning. 
who’s the professor and who’s the TA: 
Sam is Jess’s TA. It’s totally inappropriate that they have a relationship, but as long as no one finds out it’s fine (and that’s also half the fun).
who’s the knight and who’s the prince(ss)
Again, because I love a classic, Jess is the princess and Sam’s the knight. 
who’s the teacher and who’s the single parent:
Sam is a single dad and Jess is his son’s teacher. He’s cute and flustered around her when they have parent-teacher conferences. She might call him to tell him about how well Adam is doing in class a little more than she calls other parents. 
who’s the writer and who’s the editor:
Jess is the writer and Sam is the editor. 

DeanJo

who’s the werewolf and who’s the hunter: 
Jo is totally a feisty werewolf. Dean doesn’t know until they’re hunting together on a full moon but he knows her and he won’t hurt her. 
who’s the mermaid and who’s the fisherman:
Dean’s a mermaid and Jess is a fisherwoman. She tried to haul him out of the water when she saw him the first time because she thought he was drowning. 
who’s the witch and who’s the familiar:
Witch!Jo and Familiar!Dean all the way. 
who’s the barista and who’s the coffee addict:
Jo is the barista who draws patterns into Dean’s cappuccino. He didn’t get she was flirting with him until she somehow managed to write “Do you like me or what?” in his foam. 
who’s the professor and who’s the TA:
 Professor!Dean and TA!Jo. 
who’s the knight and who’s the prince(ss):
Dean is a prince and Jo is a knight who pretended to be a guy in order to become a knight. She’s so good she’s assigned to guard the prince. 
who’s the teacher and who’s the single parent:
Again, single dad!Dean and teacher!Jo who Dean is very smitten with. 
who’s the writer and who’s the editor:
Jo is a brutal editor but she’s the best in the business and Dean needs her. Boy, does he need her. 

Send me ships!