I wasn’t even factoring that in but obviously you’re right! Fiction doesn’t need to follow the rules that any sensible human does. Also, let’s talk about dubcon for a moment. IRL I’d just call that rape or coercion but in fic there’s all these different tags we can use. Dark fic vs. IRL assault are totally different things and I actually prefer having the freedom to use tags in fic that I wouldn’t IRL. As a survivor I appreciate it.
Oh definitely. Like, dubcon is usually a staple of certain tropes (fuck or die or heat/rut sex) that at times it isn’t even tagged because you know if you’re reading fuck or die or heat/rut sex that consent is going to be dubious. I mean, those tropes are completely about a lack of choice or control. Often they’re also used as a catalyst to break sexual tension, but IRL those are horrifying concepts.
But you’re right. I read somewhere (I don’t remember where so this isn’t my idea but it’s a good one) that part of the great thing about Dark Fic or Dark elements in fic is that it gives power to the person writing it. For the survivors of traumatic experiences, that’s hugely important because it gives us control over the things we once had no control over, and by labeling something like coercion as dubcon it puts the scene or event in a new light. It doesn’t erase it or minimize it (at least I don’t think it does) but kind of puts front and center that the consent was dubious at best. I also think it allows us to take a step back from it as well and that seperation can be a good thing. Now, granted, I think there should be more open and honest conversations about what consent actually is and what it means but I think those are conversations we should have as a society and a community and shouldn’t be on the shoulders of fanfic authors. (And it definitely shouldn’t be used as a way to shame or admonish fanfic authors either.)
Sorry, that got kinda rambly.
But yeah, Dark fic and assault are two different things. One’s imaginary and the other is real. And I’m glad that the freedom to tag them differently is helpful to you.