I’m one of those people who loooves debate. It’s sport to me. And, like, don’t get me wrong, I don’t do it for some kind of intellectual reason, I do it because I want to win. I love the mental challenge of agruements and the thrill of winning.
When I was in high school, (5 years ago now, which is strange to say) I was captain of the debate team, an award winning congressional debater, part of the Model UN, and I drafted legislation for Youth and Government (real legislation, too. Stuff my team argued in the State House in front of State Reps). So yeah, I fricken looove debate. I love fighting with words. It’s thrilling. I didn’t do much in college though, because the Mock Trial team was always at dumb times.
So given that it would make sense if I threw down on the internet all the time. But, I don’t. See, one of the things I was always guaranteed in debate matches was good faith arguements. No matter what side of an issue I was on or who I was debating, there was the pretense that no one was arguing to be a jackass. We debated for fun and sometimes we debated nonsense (my favorite was a Purge style piece of legislation that was just nuts) but we never really took much of it to heart. Outside of the matches and the floor meetings we hung out. We joked. We complainted about homework and got lunch and complimented each other on our skills. No one was there to be an ass.
But the internet is a strange beast. I can’t argue with people on the internet because there is no good faith. There is no changing of opinions. I can cite sources all day and I’m met with people who just don’t believe in survey data or certain sciences or like, facts. And trying to point out logical fallicies is a nightmare. It’s not about winning through intellect, it’s about winning through denial and name calling. And unfortunately it’s like that irl, too, anymore. It makes me sad, not just because I want a good word fight, but also because it’s clear too many people have just stopped caring about changing their opinions or listening.












