@unforth-ninawaters replied to your post “I’m getting that itch again to dig into fandom, pick everyone’s brain,…”
What theories? Now I’m curious too
Oh, man, I have so many, just depending on what fandom and what sub-fandom we’re talking about.
Theory Number One: Big Name Fans set the tone and level of acceptability for certain behaviors, thoughts, and beliefs within the fandom. This, as well as peer pressure, leads “smaller” fans to accept the opinions of BNFs as normal for the given fandom/sub-fandom. This is why some fandoms believe things so radically different from others, despite the fact that the people one each side are reasonably intelligent. (eg. Fan Group A says “the actor’s opinion on their character doesn’t matter and might be wrong” while Fan Group B says “we should listen to what the actor says about their character because they know them best”.)
Theory Number Two: The Rise of Anti-ism is, in part, a reaction to not having a safe outlet for teenage/young adult rejection of and rebellion against oppressive social structures. I’ve noticed quite a few similarities between young Atheists who turn away from religion for the first time and young antis in some fandoms, including their unconscious clinging to aspects of (mostly Christian) religious structure (”If you were enlightened like me, you wouldn’t be a sinner/religious/shipper. Let me tell you the truth.” “I don’t care that it helps you with some aspect of your life, it’s wrong!” “Everyone who doesn’t agree with me is a godless heathen/moron.”). It might not be the cause, but there could be a correlation between the lack of online safe places for young Atheists to express their anger due to the increasing right-leaning nature of online Atheism and Anti shipping. Add to this the fact that much of the West is dealing with tremendous political and social pressure at the moment and you get more anxious, angry young people with few outlets and the need to find some level of control in their own lives. Add fandom, and you might get Anti-ism.
Theory Number Three: Fanfiction, broadly speaking, varies on emphasis depending on the gender break down of the ship it’s written for. Obviously, there are more factors than just gender, like canon dynamics and wants/needs of the author, but there’s something drastically different between M/M and F/F fiction even in the same fandom. It’s possible that m/m is “safer” for both reader and writer to explore topics like gender, sexuality, etc., while f/f is held to a higher standard. Why exactly, I’m unsure, but I feel it has something to do with fear of female sexuality. M/M is safer because there is a separation from the author/reader and the characters (as most fans who read slash are women) but the same kind of separation isn’t present in f/f. There might also be a fear of doing female sexuality “wrong” in the current fandom climate that plays in to the lack of femslash as well.
Those are some of the big, general ones I have at the moment. I have no idea how to test any of these out in full, but they’re what I’ve been thinking about off and on for a while now.