@trisscar368
Imo, Bad Boys could be debatable but given that 1) we know Dean lies and 2) the whole episode is about how shitty John was and how happier Dean is without him, I don’t think we’re supposed to believe a werewolf did it.

Dark Side of the Moon, though, yeah. I’m of the opinion that whatever happened was deeply traumatizing but I don’t think it has to be physical. Mental abuse can do the same thing. But I don’t discount it. Maybe it was both. But yeah. That look. *shudders* A+ acting though.